CSDR will harm those it seeks to protect, says ICMA
03 February 2020 London
Image: Shutterstock
The International Capital Market Association (ICMA) and the Investment Association have reinforced calls for a delay and reforms to the Central 麻豆传媒 Depositories Regulation鈥檚 (CSDR) mandatory buy-in provisions.
CSDR鈥檚 buy-in provisions are officially slated to come into force in September but are understood to facing a push-back until early 2021. The delay is in response to
from several market sectors that its settlement discipline regime, which includes the mandatory buy-in provisions, are not fit-for-purpose.
In a letter to the European Commission, the associations warn of the potentially negative consequences for the EU鈥檚 bond market and specifically for their buy-side members, which CSDR was aimed at protecting.
鈥淥ur respective members wish to make clear that they are fully supportive of all constructive efforts, whether private or public, to improve settlement efficiency in the European Union,鈥� the letter reads.
鈥淭his includes the use of buy-in and sell-out provisions, which are an important contractual remedy for settlement fails and a useful tool for managing settlement risk,鈥� it continues. 鈥淣evertheless, our members are concerned that the buy-in provisions specified in the CSDR, while well-intentioned, will prove to be unduly harmful to the functioning, liquidity, and stability of the EU鈥檚 bond markets.鈥�
The associations further note that CSDR鈥檚 buy-in rules 鈥渄iffer legally, structurally, and economically from existing contractual buy-in remedies used in the non-cleared bond markets,鈥� which they say 鈥渦ndermines the effectiveness of EU CSDR mandatory buy-ins as a bond market settlement risk mitigant鈥�.
The provisions are widely expected to increase market risks markedly, both for liquidity providers and investors, the letter says. In turn, this could have unintentional detrimental consequences for issuers raising capital in the EU鈥檚 bond markets.
As a result, the associations are requesting reforms to CSDR鈥檚 regulatory technical standards 鈥渢o allow for a more market-sensitive and phased application of the requirements, based on a thorough evaluation of market impacts鈥�.
The concerns raised in the letter echo requests made in , including ICMA and the International 麻豆传媒 Lending Association, that was sent by the Association for Financial Markets in Europe (AFME), to the Commission on 22 January.
CSDR鈥檚 buy-in provisions are officially slated to come into force in September but are understood to facing a push-back until early 2021. The delay is in response to
from several market sectors that its settlement discipline regime, which includes the mandatory buy-in provisions, are not fit-for-purpose.
In a letter to the European Commission, the associations warn of the potentially negative consequences for the EU鈥檚 bond market and specifically for their buy-side members, which CSDR was aimed at protecting.
鈥淥ur respective members wish to make clear that they are fully supportive of all constructive efforts, whether private or public, to improve settlement efficiency in the European Union,鈥� the letter reads.
鈥淭his includes the use of buy-in and sell-out provisions, which are an important contractual remedy for settlement fails and a useful tool for managing settlement risk,鈥� it continues. 鈥淣evertheless, our members are concerned that the buy-in provisions specified in the CSDR, while well-intentioned, will prove to be unduly harmful to the functioning, liquidity, and stability of the EU鈥檚 bond markets.鈥�
The associations further note that CSDR鈥檚 buy-in rules 鈥渄iffer legally, structurally, and economically from existing contractual buy-in remedies used in the non-cleared bond markets,鈥� which they say 鈥渦ndermines the effectiveness of EU CSDR mandatory buy-ins as a bond market settlement risk mitigant鈥�.
The provisions are widely expected to increase market risks markedly, both for liquidity providers and investors, the letter says. In turn, this could have unintentional detrimental consequences for issuers raising capital in the EU鈥檚 bond markets.
As a result, the associations are requesting reforms to CSDR鈥檚 regulatory technical standards 鈥渢o allow for a more market-sensitive and phased application of the requirements, based on a thorough evaluation of market impacts鈥�.
The concerns raised in the letter echo requests made in , including ICMA and the International 麻豆传媒 Lending Association, that was sent by the Association for Financial Markets in Europe (AFME), to the Commission on 22 January.
NO FEE, NO RISK
100% ON RETURNS If you invest in only one securities finance news source this year, make sure it is your free subscription to 麻豆传媒 Finance Times
100% ON RETURNS If you invest in only one securities finance news source this year, make sure it is your free subscription to 麻豆传媒 Finance Times
